Why Stop At Pineapple? Unexpected Toppings For Pizza Bloomington Foodies Can’t Resist

At Bucceto’s, we don’t just believe that pineapple belongs on pizza. We believe a lot of unexpected ingredients make delicious pizza toppings. In our test kitchen, we’re always trying new ideas to take our pizzas to the next level. If you’re a foodie, Buccetos’ is the pizza Bloomington orders when they are looking for classic hand-tossed Italian-style pizza, but with a fun twist. If you’re a foodie looking for a new pizza flavor, try these toppings next time you are at Bucceto’s:

Clams: Yes, on pizza. Clams bring a sweet, ocean-kissed flavor that pairs beautifully with garlic and white sauce.
Pecans: A little sweet, a little nutty, and surprisingly perfect on a pizza pie.
Capers: These briny little flavor bombs are bold. Add them to a pizza with olives or smoked sausage and you’ll see why we love them.
New Potatoes: Unexpected? Definitely. Delicious? Absolutely. Thin-sliced potatoes give your pie a crispy, comforting twist.
Onion Marmalade: Sweet, rich, and deeply caramelized, it’s jam for grown-ups. It plays beautifully with smoky sausage or sharp cheeses.
Chorizo Sausage: Spicy, smoky, and packed with flavor. Chorizo turns your pizza into a fiesta.
Chili Oil: A drizzle of chili oil transforms any slice into something spicy, slick, and craveable. It’s like hot sauce, but cooler.
Barbecue Sauce: Sweet, smoky, and sticky in all the best ways. BBQ sauce replaces red sauce for a bold twist that pairs perfectly with chicken, Gouda, or onions.
Cilantro: Fresh and punchy, cilantro brings brightness to spicy pies like those with chorizo or smoked sausage.
Smoked Gouda: It’s creamy, it’s smoky, and it melts like a dream. Add it to BBQ or potato-based pizzas for instant comfort food energy.
Pine Nuts: Earthy and rich, pine nuts are perfect on pesto-based pizzas or anything with spinach and ricotta.
Broccoli: Underrated and totally snackable when roasted. Broccoli adds crunch and freshness that works on veggie-forward pizzas.

At Bucceto’s, we’re always experimenting with rich flavors and are constantly inspired by what our customers create. We invite you to take a look at our long list of pizza toppings and find a gourmet combination for you. Then, when you’re ready for pizza in Bloomington, stop by one of our two convenient locations, or order delivery or carryout online.